In your review for research papers and scientific articles submitted to conferences or journals, it would be very helpful and useful to consider providing detailed answers for the following questions.
1. Does the paper represent a technical contribution and, if so, what?
2. Is the paper well written? If not, how can it be improved?
3. Is the paper appropriately organized? If not, how should it be reorganized?
4. Can the paper be shortened without diminishing the quality of the paper or its results? If so, how?
5. Is it necessary that the paper be expanded? If so, where and how?
6. If the paper is not suitable in its current form, can it be modified to make it so? How?
7. Does the abstract give a clear summary of the results of the paper?
Comments
Post a Comment